The Bombardment of Greytown, Part Four

Solon Borland (D-AR)

Solon Borland (D-AR)

Original Stealing Cuba: parts 123456 and revisited.

The Nicaragua-Cuba Connection: parts 1, 2, 3, 4

The Bombardment of Greytown, parts 1, 2, 3, behind the scenes

On July 13, 1854, George N. Hollins, United States Navy, ordered the shelling of Greytown, a free port on Nicaragua’s Mosquito Coast, or within the United Kingdom’s Mosquito Coast protectorate, or within its own anomalous jurisdiction and outside the control of any nation. Depending on who one asked at the time, and when, any of those descriptions could apply. Setting aside the legal and direct political issues, Greytown ran itself. As a practical matter, the nations concerned recognized it as something more than property of another nation, but less than a nation of its own. Thus the United States appointed no ambassador or minister, but did dispatch a commercial agent named Joseph Fabens to look after American interests at the eastern end of the route across Nicaragua to the Pacific.

Fabens, as I’ve said before, very probably worked at least as much for the Accessory Transit Company as he did for the United States. In that capacity he sent letters back to Washington about how the local authorities seized some company property over a dispute over land use. This did not amount to a great deal of wealth, but apparently the company considered the Greytown authorities a substantial impediment to doing business as they preferred and wanted rid of them. Fabens’ dispatches on that matter failed to bring about any action on Washington’s part, but when Solon Borland intervened to save a Company captain and murderer from justice and caught a bottle to the face for his trouble, things changed.

Horace Greeley

Horace Greeley

Horace Greeley’s New York Daily Tribune printed correspondence about Greytown on August 2 and 3, 1854. He had it because Congress demanded the documents from Franklin Pierce and Pierce obliged. Those documents include two letters from William L. Marcy, Secretary of State, to Fabens. The first mentions only the Transit Company’s difficulties but promises fuller instructions on a later ship. The second letter invokes both the Company’s dispute:

notify the people of San Juan to repair the injury they have caused to the Accessory Transit Company by withholding from it the property which had been stolen and taken to San Juan, and by protecting the persons who were guilty of the felony.

and the matter that finally got a warship moving, Solon Borland’s injury:

Mr. Borland, our Minister to Central America, has represented to this Government that, while recently in San Juan, he was insulted by the authorities or people of that place. An indignity offered to the nation, as well as to him individually, cannot be permitted to pass unnoticed. If done by order of the authorities of the place, they must answer for it in their assumed political character. Nothing short of an apology for the outrage will save the place from the infliction that such an act justly merits. It is expected that this apology will be promptly made, and satisfactory assurance given to Commander Hollins of future good conduct toward the United States and public functionaries who may in future be at that place.

The orders that James Cochran Dobbins, Secretary of the Navy, gave Hollins repeat both concerns:

The property of the American citizens interested in the Accessory Transit Company, it is said, has been unlawfully detained by persons residing in Greytown. Apprehension is felt that further outrages will be committed. Our Minister, Mr. Borland, has been treated with rudeness and disrespect.

Maybe Washington wouldn’t send a ship just to settle things up for the Transit Company, but it would settle things for the Transit Company once it arrived to get some kind of reckoning for the attack on Borland. Thus the Transit Company’s dispute with Greytown and Solon Borland’s injured face come together as the USS Cyane arrives in Greytown’s harbor. The Company men must have smiled when they heard the news.

Your input is welcome

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.